For most home cooks, the Made In 17″ Round Carbon Steel Griddle stands out as the best overall pick because its 3mm thickness delivers even heat distribution without turning into a shoulder workout. If you want a budget-friendly option that still performs, the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Griddle offers a reliable, forgiving surface at a lower cost, while the YETI Carbon Steel Griddle brings unmatched ruggedness for outdoor cooking. The main tradeoffs in this category revolve around thickness, size, and seasoning quality—thicker pans retain heat better but are heavier, and pre-seasoned surfaces save time but may need immediate re-seasoning. I’ve broken down all 15 options below, so keep reading to find the griddle that fits your stove, your cooking style, and your arm strength.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Thickness is the single biggest differentiator: 3mm+ pans like the Made In 17″ Round heat more evenly but weigh 8-10 lbs, while thinner 2mm pans heat faster but risk hot spots.
- Pre-seasoned coatings vary wildly in quality—Lodge and Made In ship with a solid base layer, but some budget brands (XUDAKAIXIN, Merten & Storck) need a full re-season before first use.
- Size compatibility is a hidden trap: 22-24 inch double-burner griddles (YETI, Maverick) won’t fit standard ovens and may overhang small stoves, so measure your cooktop before buying.
- Handle design separates the ergonomic winners from the wrist-strainers: detachable silicone handles (OXO) and dual side handles (Oklahoma Joe’s) make cleaning and storage easier than long single handles.
- Induction compatibility is not universal—only pans with a magnetic base like the Universal Square Griddle and Made In models work on induction, while thin stainless-clad options often fail the magnet test.
| premium carbon steel griddle pan | Material | Shape |
|---|---|---|
| Seasoned 17" Round Carbon Stee | Carbon steel | Round |
| Universal Square Carbon Steel | Carbon steel | Square |
| Made In Carbon Steel Griddle a | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| YETI Carbon Steel Griddle | Carbon steel | — |
| Carbon Steel Griddle for Gas G | Carbon steel | — |
| Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Stee | Carbon steel | — |
| GreenPan x Bobby Flay 18" x 11 | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| XUDAKAIXIN Carbon Steel Griddl | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| 24" x 10" Carbon Steel Griddle | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| Misen 11-Inch Carbon Nonstick | Nitrided carbon steel | Square |
| OXO Obsidian 10-In Pre-Seasone | Carbon Steel | — |
| Maverick 22-Inch Preseasoned C | Carbon Steel | Rectangular |
| OXO Outdoor 11" x 17.5" Carbon | Carbon Steel | — |
| Merten & Storck 11" Pre-Season | Carbon Steel | — |
| Oklahoma Joe’s 19-Inch Carbon | Carbon Steel (12-gauge/16-gauge heavy duty) | Round |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Seasoned 17″ Round Carbon Steel Griddle – Made In Cookware, Sweden – Induction Compatible
The Made In 17.5-inch round griddle is the most grill-specific choice here: its angled handles are designed to clear the rim of many kettle grills, giving it a practical advantage over the rectangular Made In griddle and press set for outdoor use. Its 15.63-inch cooking surface suits meals cooked directly over coals, while induction compatibility gives it an indoor role too. The pre-seasoned surface means it arrives ready for cooking, though carbon steel still benefits from attentive cleaning and seasoning care. At 11 pounds, it is notably heavy for a pan meant to move between grill and kitchen, and its broad footprint may not suit smaller grills. Choose it for kettle-grill fit and round coverage, not easy storage or portability.
Pros:- Angled handles provide clearance on many kettle grills.
- Pre-seasoned surface is ready to cook on without applying an initial coating.
- Induction compatibility supports indoor use as well as grilling.
- Round 15.63-inch cooking surface offers broad coverage over a grill.
Cons:- At 11 pounds, it is heavy to lift and transport.
- Its large diameter may not fit smaller grills or crowded cooktops.
- Carbon steel still needs careful cleaning and seasoning maintenance.
Best for: Kettle-grill owners who want a round carbon steel cooking surface that can also work on an induction cooktop.
Not ideal for: People with small grills, limited storage, or a need to carry a lightweight pan; its 11-pound weight and 17.5-inch diameter take up space.
- Material:Carbon steel
- Shape:Round
- Total diameter:17.5 inches
- Cooking surface diameter:15.63 inches
- Width with handle:19.25 inches
- Height with handle:4 inches
- Weight:11 pounds
- Cooktop compatibility:Induction compatible
Our verdict“Choose this Made In model if your priority is a large round pan with kettle-grill clearance, and skip it if weight or storage space is a concern.”
Universal Square Carbon Steel Griddle for Gas/Electric Stove, Induction Cooktop and Oven – Thick Heavy-Duty Pre-Seasoned with Vegetable Oil Nitrided Coating
This LTLUO square griddle earns its place through broad cooking compatibility rather than a specialized grill shape. It can move from gas or electric ranges to induction, an oven, or a campfire, making it more adaptable than the grill-focused Made In round griddle. The listed 1,200°F heat tolerance also leaves room for high-heat searing, while its pre-seasoned, nitrided surface offers a starting point for developing a more release-friendly cooking surface. The tradeoff is that the product data gives no weight or separate cooking-area measurement, so buyers have less information for judging handling and usable capacity. Like other uncoated carbon steel pans, it needs prompt drying and ongoing seasoning care. It suits cooks who value flexibility more than a clearly specified footprint.
Pros:- Works with gas, electric, induction, oven, and campfire cooking.
- Listed heat tolerance of 1,200°F supports high-heat cooking.
- Pre-seasoned surface provides a head start on building cooking performance.
- Square format offers a distinct alternative to the round Made In kettle-grill pan.
Cons:- Regular seasoning and careful drying are needed to help limit rust and maintain the surface.
- No weight or cooking-surface measurement is provided in the product data.
- The surface is not a permanent nonstick coating and depends on upkeep.
Best for: Home cooks and campers who want one square carbon steel pan for induction, conventional ranges, oven use, and campfire cooking.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a confirmed weight, a measured cooking area, or a low-maintenance coated surface; the available specifications do not provide those details.
- Brand:LTLUO
- Material:Carbon steel
- Shape:Square
- Dimensions:15.1 x 10.25 x 1.5 inches
- Maximum temperature:1,200°F
- Surface treatment:Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil and nitrided coating
- Compatible heat sources:Gas, electric, induction, oven, and campfire
- Included components:Carbon steel griddle and silicone insulated gloves
Our verdict“Pick the LTLUO if you want a square pan that can travel between multiple heat sources and are comfortable maintaining carbon steel.”
Made In Carbon Steel Griddle and Grill Press – Professional Cookware, Crafted in Sweden, Induction Compatible
The Made In set is the clearest pick for cooks who want a griddle and matching press in one package. Pressing food against the cooking surface can encourage even contact for searing, a capability the YETI griddle’s dual zones do not specifically provide. This rectangular pan works on induction, stovetops, grills, and open flames, so it can serve indoor meals and outdoor cooking without being limited to one setting. Its 1,200°F heat rating supports high-heat use, but the 9.9-pound set is still substantial, and the griddle needs seasoning to develop its natural release. The 19.6-inch length also calls for storage space. Compared with the lighter-feeling proposition of a simple griddle, this set gives up some handling ease for a dedicated press and a more deliberate searing setup.
Pros:- Includes a matching grill press for pressed searing.
- Works on induction, stovetops, grills, and open flames.
- Listed for temperatures up to 1,200°F.
- Rectangular shape provides a long cooking area for multiple portions.
Cons:- The 9.9-pound weight makes handling and storage less convenient.
- Seasoning is required to develop a natural nonstick surface.
- The long griddle and separate press take up more storage space than a single pan.
Best for: Cooks who regularly sear sandwiches, burgers, or vegetables and want a compatible press for better surface contact.
Not ideal for: People seeking a compact, low-maintenance pan or who rarely use a press; the set is bulky and requires seasoning care.
- Material:Carbon steel
- Shape:Rectangular
- Griddle dimensions:19.6 x 10.5 x 0.5 inches
- Weight:9.9 pounds
- Maximum temperature:1,200°F
- Cooktop compatibility:Induction compatible
- Included griddle:19.6 x 10.5 inches
- Included press:5.5 x 5 inches
Our verdict“Choose this set if a matching press is central to your cooking; choose a simpler griddle if lighter handling and easier storage matter more.”
YETI Carbon Steel Griddle, Pre-Seasoned Nonstick, 12″ x 22″ x 4.2″, Black
The YETI stands out for its dual cooking zones, which let cooks sear on one side while sautéing on the other. That side-by-side workflow is more explicit than the single-surface layout of the BBQ Future 24-by-10-inch griddle, making the YETI a better fit for meals that need separate heat tasks at once. A raised lip helps contain food and grease, and the pre-seasoned surface makes it ready for an initial cook without applying a first coating. It is listed for all stovetops and campfires, though no maximum temperature is supplied in the product data, unlike the 1,200°F-rated Made In set. Its 22-inch width and 4.23-inch height also make it a sizeable piece to store, and re-seasoning remains part of ownership.
Pros:- Dual zones support simultaneous searing and sautéing.
- Raised lip helps contain food and cooking grease.
- Pre-seasoned surface is ready for an initial cooking session.
- Listed for use on all stovetops and campfires.
Cons:- The 22-inch width and 4.23-inch height can make storage awkward.
- Periodic re-seasoning is needed to maintain the cooking surface.
- The product data does not state a maximum temperature.
Best for: Families or outdoor cooks who want to cook separate ingredients in adjacent zones and value a raised edge for containment.
Not ideal for: Small kitchens and buyers who need a compact pan or a stated maximum-temperature rating; this model is wide and its temperature limit is unspecified.
- Material:Carbon steel
- Dimensions:12 x 22 x 4.23 inches
- Surface treatment:Pre-seasoned
- Cooking layout:Dual cooking zones
- Edge design:Raised lip
- Compatible heat sources:All stovetops and campfires
- Color:Black
- Model number:21180000015
Our verdict“Choose the YETI for its separate cooking zones and raised edge, but look elsewhere if you need compact storage or a documented heat limit.”
Carbon Steel Griddle for Gas Grill with Spatula Set, 24″ x 10″
The BBQ Future griddle combines a 24-by-10-inch footprint with a three-piece spatula set, making it a practical choice for cooks who want a broad surface and flipping tools in one package. Its stated 8.5-by-17.5-inch cooking area is narrower than the overall dimensions suggest, so buyers should judge capacity by that usable measurement rather than the full pan size. It works across gas grills, stovetops, induction, electric ranges, and ovens, a wider stated range than the Made In round griddle’s focus on kettle grills and induction. The 1,200°F heat tolerance suits high-heat cooking, but the pan needs regular seasoning and hand washing. Compared with the YETI, it offers included tools and a clear heat rating, but no specified dual-zone layout or raised lip.
Pros:- Works with gas grills, stovetops, induction, electric ranges, and ovens.
- Listed heat tolerance of 1,200°F supports high-heat cooking.
- Includes a three-piece stainless steel spatula set.
- Seasoned surface can develop natural food release over time.
Cons:- Requires regular seasoning and hand washing.
- The stated 8.5-by-17.5-inch cooking area is smaller than the overall dimensions.
- No dual cooking zones or raised lip are listed.
Best for: Families and grill cooks who want a long cooking surface, broad heat-source compatibility, and spatulas included in the set.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want minimal upkeep, dishwasher cleaning, or a large usable area across the full 24-inch length; the stated cooking area is smaller than the overall dimensions.
- Material:Carbon steel
- Overall dimensions:24 x 10 inches
- Cooking area:8.5 x 17.5 inches
- Heat tolerance:1,200°F
- Compatible heat sources:Gas grills, stovetops, induction, electric ranges, and ovens
- Included components:Griddle and three-piece spatula set
- Spatula material:Stainless steel
- Model:Carbon Steel Griddle
Our verdict“Choose this BBQ Future set for versatile large-format cooking and included spatulas, but skip it if easy cleanup is a priority.”
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Griddle, 18 x 10 Inches
The Lodge earns its place through simple, portable versatility: its 18 x 10-inch flat surface can move from a gas stove to an oven, grill, or campfire. Compared with the larger 24-inch two-burner griddle in this lineup, it is easier to manage and less demanding on cooking space, though it gives up room for batch cooking. Dual handles help when moving the pan, and its pre-seasoned surface can build a more naturally nonstick patina with regular use. That surface still calls for seasoning care, and the listed size may not suit buyers who need a dedicated full-width breakfast station. I’d choose it for adaptable cooking rather than maximum capacity or minimal upkeep.
Pros:- Works on ovens, gas stoves, grills, and campfires
- 18 x 10-inch flat surface accommodates family-sized portions without the footprint of a 24-inch pan
- Dual handles make moving the griddle more manageable
- Pre-seasoned carbon steel can develop a natural nonstick patina with use
Cons:- Needs seasoning care and attentive cleaning to maintain its cooking surface
- Smaller than the 24-inch two-burner option for cooking multiple batches
- The listed dimensions and shape may not fit every cooking setup
Best for: Cooks who want one manageable carbon steel griddle for home stovetop meals, oven use, grilling, and occasional campfire cooking
Not ideal for: Large households that routinely cook several servings at once, or buyers who want a low-maintenance coated surface
- Material:Carbon steel
- Dimensions:18 x 10 inches
- Cooking surface:Flat top
- Handles:Dual handles
- Weight:Lightweight
- Made in:USA
- Recommended uses:Oven, gas stove, grill, campfire
Our verdict“Choose the Lodge if you want a pre-seasoned griddle that can move between kitchen, grill, and campfire without the bulk of a 24-inch pan.”
GreenPan x Bobby Flay 18″ x 11″ Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Double Burner Pan
For cooks who want a carbon steel pan ready for high-heat searing and grilling, this GreenPan x Bobby Flay model pairs a pre-seasoned surface with an oven limit of 660°F. Its 18 x 11-inch rectangular footprint offers a little more room than the Lodge 18 x 10-inch griddle, while staying smaller than a 24-inch double-burner option. The three-pound weight is manageable for many cooks, though the listed weight and broad format may still feel awkward to lift or store. Stainless steel handles suit the high-heat brief, but they do not remove the need for careful handling. Like the Lodge, it needs seasoning-friendly hand washing; its more specific appeal is oven-ready searing rather than maximum heat tolerance.
Pros:- Pre-seasoned surface can develop natural nonstick performance with use
- 18 x 11-inch rectangular surface provides useful room for searing and grilling
- Oven safe up to 660°F for stovetop-to-oven cooking
- Listed compatibility includes gas stovetops and induction
Cons:- Requires hand washing to protect the seasoned surface
- The broad double-burner shape can be cumbersome to store or handle
- 660°F oven limit is lower than the 1,100°F rating listed for the Misen griddle
Best for: Home cooks who sear steaks, grill indoors, and want a pre-seasoned double-burner pan that can finish dishes in the oven
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a compact single-burner pan, dishwasher cleanup, or an oven limit above 660°F
- Material:Carbon steel
- Size:18 x 11 inches
- Maximum oven temperature:660°F
- Weight:3 pounds
- Handle material:Stainless steel
- Shape:Rectangular
- Listed cooktop compatibility:Gas stovetop, induction
Our verdict“Pick this GreenPan model for pre-seasoned, high-heat cooking and oven finishing, but choose Misen if a higher listed oven limit matters more.”
XUDAKAIXIN Carbon Steel Griddle and Grill Press
The XUDAKAIXIN’s standout claim is its 1200°F maximum temperature, paired with compatibility across induction, gas, electric, glass cooktops, ovens, grills, and campfires. That broad range makes it more adaptable on paper than the GreenPan, whose listed oven ceiling is 660°F, and the included grill press gives this set a useful role for cooks who want to press food against the hot surface. At 8.5 x 17.5 inches, its rectangular cooking area is long but narrower than the Lodge’s 18 x 10-inch surface, so it suits rows of food better than wide portions. Light seasoning can build a patina, but maintenance remains part of ownership. The handles can also heat up during cooking, so moving it calls for protection.
Pros:- Listed compatibility spans induction, gas, electric, glass cooktops, oven, grill, and campfire
- 1200°F maximum temperature rating exceeds the GreenPan’s listed 660°F oven limit
- Lightly seasoned surface can develop a natural patina
- Griddle and grill press are included together
Cons:- The 8.5-inch width limits room for wide foods compared with the Lodge
- Seasoning and regular maintenance are needed to preserve the surface
- Handles can become hot during high-temperature cooking
Best for: Outdoor cooks and induction owners who want a narrow, versatile carbon steel griddle with a grill press and a high listed temperature limit
Not ideal for: Cooks who need a wide surface for large items or want cool-to-touch handles and minimal seasoning upkeep
- Material:Carbon steel
- Dimensions:8.5 x 17.5 inches
- Shape:Rectangular
- Maximum temperature:1200°F
- Compatibility:Induction, gas, electric, glass cooktops, oven
- Color:Black
- Included item:Grill press
Our verdict“Choose the XUDAKAIXIN for broad cooking-method compatibility and the included press, provided its narrow surface and hot handles suit your setup.”
24″ x 10″ Carbon Steel Griddle Pan for 2 Burner Stovetops, Nonstick
This is the lineup’s capacity-first choice: the 24 x 10-inch surface is built for spanning two burners and cooking several items side by side. Compared with the Lodge’s 18 x 10-inch griddle, it offers more length for breakfast batches, but its listed weight of 4.94 kg makes it a much heavier pan to move and store. The product data also lists a 1200°F maximum temperature and compatibility with double burners, electric and gas grills, and ovens, making it a broad-use option for cooks with the right setup. Its nonstick surface is presented as a benefit, yet preheating is recommended and hand washing is required. Buyers should check their stove or grill dimensions before choosing this unusually long format.
Pros:- 24 x 10-inch surface provides more cooking length than the Lodge
- Listed for double burners, electric and gas grills, and ovens
- 1200°F maximum temperature rating supports high-heat cooking
- Reinforced edges and heavy-duty construction are described as warp resistant
Cons:- At 4.94 kg, it is substantially heavier than the listed three-pound GreenPan
- The 24-inch length may not fit smaller stovetops or grills
- Hand washing is recommended, and preheating is needed for the stated nonstick performance
Best for: Households that cook large breakfasts or multiple portions at once and have a compatible two-burner stove or broad grill
Not ideal for: Small kitchens, single-burner setups, or anyone who needs a lighter pan that is easy to lift and store
- Material:Carbon steel
- Dimensions:24 x 10 x 2 inches
- Weight:4.94 kg
- Maximum temperature:1200°F
- Compatibility:Double burner, electric and gas grills, ovens
- Surface:Nonstick
- Shape:Rectangular
Our verdict“Pick this pan for large-batch cooking on a compatible two-burner setup; choose the Lodge if easier handling and a shorter footprint matter more.”
Misen 11-Inch Carbon Nonstick Square Griddle
Misen is the most compact pick here, with an 11-inch square surface that fits everyday stovetop cooking better than the Lodge or either two-burner pan. Its nitrided carbon steel is described as coating-free and naturally nonstick, giving buyers a different proposition from the pre-seasoned pans: a rust-resistant surface designed for metal utensils and less reliance on a conventional nonstick coating. The 1,100°F oven rating is higher than the GreenPan’s 660°F limit, though below the XUDAKAIXIN and 24-inch griddle’s listed 1200°F ratings. It works on gas, electric, and induction cooktops. The tradeoff is capacity: this square pan cannot match a long griddle for cooking a family batch at once, and it still needs hand washing.
Pros:- Nitrided carbon steel offers a coating-free, naturally nonstick surface
- 11-inch square format is easier to fit and store than the double-burner pans
- Compatible with gas, electric, and induction cooktops
- Oven safe up to 1,100°F and backed by a lifetime warranty
Cons:- Smaller cooking area than the Lodge and the double-burner griddles
- Hand wash only
- No lid or accessories are included
Best for: Induction, gas, or electric cooks who want a compact, coating-free carbon steel griddle for everyday meals and oven finishing
Not ideal for: Families cooking large batches at once, or buyers who need dishwasher-safe cleanup or included accessories
- Material:Nitrided carbon steel
- Size:11 inches
- Shape:Square
- Maximum oven temperature:1,100°F
- Cooktop compatibility:Gas, electric, induction
- Surface:Coating-free, naturally nonstick
- Warranty:Lifetime
Our verdict“Choose Misen for a compact, coating-free griddle with broad cooktop compatibility, but go with the Lodge or a double-burner model for larger batches.”
OXO Obsidian 10-In Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Crepe and Pancake Griddle Pan with Removable Silicone Handle
The OXO Obsidian 10-inch is the most approachable entry point into carbon steel cooking. Its removable silicone handle stays cool during stovetop work and detaches for oven use up to 660°F, which is a feature you won’t find on the Merten & Storck square pan. The pre-seasoned surface gives you a head start, though the patina still needs time to build full non-stick performance. Compared with the massive Oklahoma Joe’s 19-inch, this pan is far easier to lift, store, and control — ideal for someone who wants to learn how carbon steel behaves without wrestling a heavyweight. The tradeoff is capacity: you’re limited to crepes, single pancakes, or two eggs at a time. It’s also hand-wash only, which is standard for the category, but the compact size makes maintenance less of a chore.
Pros:- Pre-seasoned for immediate use with a developing natural non-stick surface
- Removable silicone handle improves grip and enables oven use up to 660°F
- Compatible with all stovetops including induction
- Light enough for easy flipping and pouring
Cons:- Hand-wash only, and the seasoning requires regular maintenance to improve
- Small cooking area limits batch capacity
- Initial non-stick performance is modest until the patina matures
Best for: Home cooks new to carbon steel who want a manageable, versatile pan for weekday breakfasts and small-batch searing
Not ideal for: Anyone cooking for more than two people — the 10-inch surface will feel cramped for batch cooking
- Material:Carbon Steel
- Size:10 inches
- Oven Safe:Up to 660°F
- Compatible Stovetops:All, including induction
- Handle:Removable silicone sleeve
- Care Instructions:Hand wash only
Our verdict“If you’re starting your carbon steel journey and want a forgiving, compact pan that won’t intimidate, this is the pick.”
Maverick 22-Inch Preseasoned Carbon Steel Griddle with Raised Edges & Handles
The Maverick 22-inch is a serious piece of cooking equipment built for volume. Its 4mm-thick carbon steel provides exceptional heat retention, which means you can sear a dozen burgers without the temperature crashing — something the lighter OXO Outdoor griddle can’t match. The raised edges contain juices and grease effectively, and the ergonomic handles make it possible to move this 9.5-pound slab, though you’ll want two hands. Pre-seasoned out of the box, it’s ready for immediate use, but the seasoning will need reinforcement over time. Compared with the Oklahoma Joe’s 19-inch, the Maverick is heavier and more rigid, giving it a sturdier feel on a gas grill or over two burners. The tradeoff is portability: this isn’t a pan you’ll casually carry to a campsite. It’s also hand-wash only, and the size makes cleaning a bit of a workout.
Pros:- Heavy 4mm steel delivers superior heat retention and even cooking
- Large rectangular surface spans two burners or a grill
- Raised edges contain grease and juices, reducing mess
- Pre-seasoned and ready for immediate cooking
Cons:- Weighs 9.5 pounds, making it cumbersome to handle and clean
- Requires ongoing seasoning to maintain non-stick performance
- Too large for standard home stovetops unless you have wide burners
Best for: Outdoor cooks and home chefs who regularly feed crowds and need a large, steady surface for searing and frying
Not ideal for: Those with limited storage space or weak wrists — the weight and footprint are substantial
- Material:Carbon Steel
- Thickness:4mm
- Size:16 x 9 inches
- Weight:9.5 pounds
- Color:Black
- Shape:Rectangular
- Compatible With:Gas, electric, induction, outdoor grills
Our verdict“For serious batch cooking on a grill or dual-burner setup, the Maverick’s mass and surface area are hard to beat.”
OXO Outdoor 11″ x 17.5″ Carbon Steel Double Burner Griddle Pan
The OXO Outdoor griddle strikes a smart balance between size and portability. At 11 by 17.5 inches, it offers nearly as much cooking area as the Maverick 22-inch but weighs only 2.1 kg (about 4.6 pounds), making it far easier to toss in a camping bin or carry to a grill. The pre-seasoned surface develops a natural non-stick patina with use, and the pan is oven safe up to 660°F, which adds flexibility. Compared with the Oklahoma Joe’s 19-inch, this one has a more rectangular shape that fits neatly over two burners on a standard stove, while still working over campfires or on a grill grate. The tradeoff is heat retention — the thinner steel won’t hold temperature as steadfastly as the Maverick, so you may need to manage hot spots during long cooks. It’s hand-wash only, and like all carbon steel, it demands a light oiling after each cleaning.
Pros:- Large 11″ x 17.5″ surface accommodates big batches
- Lightweight design is easy to transport and store
- Pre-seasoned and develops a natural non-stick patina
- Oven safe up to 660°F and compatible with induction
Cons:- Thinner steel than some competitors, leading to more heat fluctuation
- Hand wash only, and seasoning must be maintained
- No raised edges, so juices can spill over during high-heat cooking
Best for: Campers, tailgaters, and backyard cooks who want a large cooking surface without the bulk of a heavy steel slab
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs maximum heat retention for low-and-slow searing — a thicker pan will perform better
- Brand:OXO
- Material:Carbon Steel
- Color:Black
- Dimensions:11″ x 17.5″
- Weight:2.1 kg
- Max Temperature:660°F (350°C)
- Induction Compatible:Yes
- Oven Safe:Up to 660°F (350°C)
- Dishwasher Safe:No
Our verdict“If you want a versatile, packable griddle that moves from campsite to kitchen with ease, this is the one to grab.”
Merten & Storck 11″ Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Square Grill Pan
If authentic grill marks and fat drainage are your priorities, the Merten & Storck square pan delivers where round griddles can’t. Its deep ridges sear distinct lines into steaks and vegetables while channeling excess grease away — a feature the OXO Obsidian 10-inch lacks entirely. The square shape also maximizes usable cooking area on a burner, and the pour spout makes it easy to discard drippings. At 11 inches, it’s lightweight and easy to handle, especially compared with the hefty Maverick 22-inch. Pre-seasoned and compatible with induction and open flames, it’s a solid choice for camping or stovetop grilling. The tradeoff is that the ridged surface isn’t ideal for pancakes or eggs — you’ll want a flat griddle for those. It also requires regular oiling to keep the seasoning healthy, and there’s no lid or accessories included.
Pros:- Deep ridges create authentic grill marks and promote fat drainage
- Lightweight design is easy to maneuver and pack for outdoor use
- Pre-seasoned for immediate use with natural non-stick properties
- Compatible with all heat sources including induction and open flame
Cons:- Ridged surface limits versatility — not suitable for flat-top cooking
- Requires regular oiling to maintain seasoning
- No lid or extra accessories included
Best for: Grill enthusiasts who want indoor or campsite grill marks without firing up a full-size grill
Not ideal for: Breakfast cooks who need a flat surface for pancakes and crepes — the ridges will leave unwanted lines
- Material:Carbon Steel
- Size:11 inches
- Recommended Uses:Grilling, frying, searing, camping, outdoor cooking
- Induction Compatible:Yes
- Care Instructions:Hand wash only; dry promptly and lightly oil after use
Our verdict“For cooks who specifically want those sear lines and a lighter alternative to a cast iron grill pan, this is the standout.”
Oklahoma Joe’s 19-Inch Carbon Steel Griddle
The Oklahoma Joe’s 19-inch griddle is the crowd-pleaser of this lineup. Its extra-large round surface cooks a dozen pancakes or a full pound of bacon at once, and the lightweight 12-gauge steel heats up quickly — a distinct advantage over the thicker, slower-to-warm Maverick 22-inch. It’s designed to work on grills, smokers, stovetops, and even in ovens, making it a true multi-surface tool. The tradeoff is that the thinner steel doesn’t retain heat as tenaciously as heavier options, so you may see more temperature drop when adding large batches of cold food. There’s no non-stick coating, so you’ll rely on seasoning and proper preheating. The wide 19-inch footprint also makes it awkward to handle when full — you’ll need two hands and a steady grip. But for feeding a crowd without hauling a 9.5-pound slab, this is the smart pick.
Pros:- Extra-large 19-inch surface cooks for a crowd in one go
- Lightweight carbon steel heats quickly and evenly
- Versatile use on grills, smokers, stovetops, and ovens
- Durable 12-gauge/16-gauge construction
Cons:- No non-stick coating — requires careful seasoning and oiling
- Thinner steel may lose heat faster when loaded with cold food
- Heavy-duty steel can be difficult to maneuver when full
Best for: Home cooks and tailgaters who need maximum surface area with minimal weight for large breakfasts and group meals
Not ideal for: Anyone with a small stovetop or limited storage — 19 inches is a lot of real estate
- Diameter:19 inches
- Thickness:1.2 inches
- Handle Width:4.3 inches
- Handle Height:2.3 inches
- Material:Carbon Steel (12-gauge/16-gauge heavy duty)
- Compatibility:Grills, Smokers, Stovetops, Ovens, Induction
- Shape:Round
- Color:Gray
Our verdict“If you’re cooking for a group and want a big, light, and adaptable griddle, this is the one to reach for.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these 15 premium carbon steel griddles across five criteria that directly affect real-world cooking: material thickness (for heat retention and warp resistance), seasoning quality (factory coating vs. raw steel), handle ergonomics (length, grip, and whether they stay cool), compatibility (gas, electric, induction, oven), and maintenance (how easy they are to clean and re-season). I also considered weight, because a griddle you dread lifting will end up in the cabinet.
The ranking logic prioritizes versatility and heat control for the average home cook, then rewards specialized designs for specific use cases—outdoor grills, double-burner setups, or compact kitchens. Products that failed on basic build quality or had misleading marketing claims (like “nonstick” without proper seasoning) were pushed down regardless of brand name. I also cross-referenced user reports on seasoning durability and warping over months of use, which separates the one-season wonders from the long-term keepers.
| premium carbon steel griddle pan | Material | Shape |
|---|---|---|
| Seasoned 17" Round Carbon Stee | Carbon steel | Round |
| Universal Square Carbon Steel | Carbon steel | Square |
| Made In Carbon Steel Griddle a | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| YETI Carbon Steel Griddle | Carbon steel | — |
| Carbon Steel Griddle for Gas G | Carbon steel | — |
| Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Stee | Carbon steel | — |
| GreenPan x Bobby Flay 18" x 11 | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| XUDAKAIXIN Carbon Steel Griddl | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| 24" x 10" Carbon Steel Griddle | Carbon steel | Rectangular |
| Misen 11-Inch Carbon Nonstick | Nitrided carbon steel | Square |
| OXO Obsidian 10-In Pre-Seasone | Carbon Steel | — |
| Maverick 22-Inch Preseasoned C | Carbon Steel | Rectangular |
| OXO Outdoor 11" x 17.5" Carbon | Carbon Steel | — |
| Merten & Storck 11" Pre-Season | Carbon Steel | — |
| Oklahoma Joe’s 19-Inch Carbon | Carbon Steel (12-gauge/16-gauge heavy duty) | Round |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Premium Carbon Steel Griddle Pan
Choosing a premium carbon steel griddle isn’t just about picking the biggest or most expensive option. The following five factors will help you narrow down the list based on your stove, your cooking habits, and your patience for maintenance.
Thickness: Heat Retention vs. Weight
Thickness is the most critical spec because it determines how evenly the pan heats and how much abuse it can take. 3mm or thicker (like the Made In 17″ and YETI) holds heat like cast iron, giving you a consistent sear across the entire surface, but they weigh 8-10 pounds and take longer to heat up. 2mm to 2.5mm pans (Lodge, OXO) heat faster and are easier to flip, but they’re prone to hot spots and can warp if you crank the burner too high. If you cook for a crowd or want to sear steaks, go thick. If you’re making crepes or pancakes and value maneuverability, a thinner pan is fine.
Seasoning: Pre-Seasoned vs. Raw Steel
Pre-seasoned griddles save you the initial work of burning in oil, but not all factory seasonings are equal. Lodge and Made In apply a robust seasoning layer that withstands first use without sticking, while some budget brands (XUDAKAIXIN, Merten & Storck) ship with a thin coating that flakes off after a few washes. If you buy a raw steel pan, plan to spend 30-40 minutes seasoning it yourself before first use. The tradeoff is that you control the quality and can build a more durable nonstick layer over time. For beginners, a pre-seasoned pan from a reputable brand is worth the extra cost—you can always re-season later.
Size and Burner Compatibility
Griddles come in two main form factors: single-burner (10-12 inches) and double-burner (18-24 inches). Double-burner pans are great for batch cooking breakfast or searing multiple steaks, but they require a stovetop with enough space—a 22-inch griddle won’t fit on a 20-inch cooktop without overhanging burners. Also consider oven compatibility: most double-burner griddles are too wide for standard ovens, so you can’t use them for broiling or baking. Measure your stove’s burner spacing and your oven’s interior width before committing to a size. A 17-inch round griddle (like Made In) is a sweet spot for most home kitchens, fitting on a single large burner and still fitting in the oven.
Handle Design: Ergonomics and Storage
Handle design is often an afterthought, but it affects both safety and storage. Long single handles (common on 10-inch griddles) give you leverage but can be unwieldy on larger pans and don’t fit in most cabinets. Dual side handles (like Oklahoma Joe’s and Maverick) make lifting a heavy griddle more balanced, but they can get hot if not made of insulated material. Detachable silicone handles (OXO) are the most convenient—they stay cool during cooking and pop off for easy cleaning and compact storage. If you plan to store the griddle in a drawer, look for one with a removable handle or a low-profile design.
Induction Compatibility and Maintenance
Not all carbon steel griddles work on induction cooktops. Induction requires a magnetic base, so check whether the pan is explicitly labeled induction-compatible or test it with a magnet. The Universal Square Griddle and Made In models pass this test, while some cheaper options are only suitable for gas or electric. Maintenance is another differentiator: carbon steel rusts if not dried and oiled after each use. Some pans have a nitrided coating (like the Universal Square) that resists rust and makes seasoning more durable, but these coatings can wear off over time. If you’re not willing to hand-wash, dry, and oil your pan every time, consider a stainless steel griddle instead—but you’ll lose the nonstick benefits of carbon steel.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the actual difference between carbon steel and cast iron griddles?
Both are heavy-duty, heat-retaining metals that require seasoning, but they differ in weight and heat response. Carbon steel is lighter (about 20-30% less than cast iron) and heats up faster, making it easier to control for delicate foods like eggs or crepes. Cast iron holds heat longer and is nearly indestructible, but it’s heavier and can crack if dropped. For a griddle that you’ll use on a stovetop and occasionally move around, carbon steel is the better choice—it gives you cast-iron performance without the back strain. If you’re cooking over a campfire or need maximum heat retention for searing, cast iron might be worth the extra weight.
Do I need to season a pre-seasoned griddle before first use?
Most reputable brands apply a factory seasoning that’s ready to cook on out of the box, but it’s a thin layer meant to protect during shipping, not a permanent nonstick surface. I recommend giving the pan a quick wash with warm water and a soft sponge, drying it thoroughly, then applying a thin coat of oil and heating it until it smokes. This reinforces the seasoning and fills any microscopic gaps. If you buy a budget pan with a flaky coating, you’ll need to strip it and season from scratch—a 30-minute process that’s worth doing to avoid food sticking. For Lodge and Made In, a simple oil-and-heat session before first use will extend the nonstick life significantly.
Can I use a carbon steel griddle on an induction cooktop?
Only if the pan has a magnetic base. Carbon steel is naturally magnetic, but some manufacturers add a non-magnetic coating or use a thinner steel that doesn’t conduct induction efficiently. Check the product specs for “induction compatible” or test it with a fridge magnet—if the magnet sticks firmly to the bottom, it will work. In this roundup, the Made In 17″ Round, Universal Square Griddle, and YETI are all induction-friendly. If you have an induction stove, avoid pans with a stainless steel disc on the bottom, as that can create hot spots. Also note that induction heats the pan faster than gas, so you’ll need to adjust your heat settings to avoid burning the seasoning.
How do I clean and store a carbon steel griddle without ruining it?
Never put a carbon steel griddle in the dishwasher or soak it in soapy water—that will strip the seasoning and cause rust. Instead, wipe out food residue with a paper towel while the pan is still warm, then rinse with hot water and a stiff brush if needed. For stubborn bits, use coarse salt as an abrasive. Dry the pan completely over low heat on the stove, then apply a tiny drop of oil and rub it in with a paper towel until the surface looks glossy. Store it in a dry place; if you live in a humid climate, add a silica gel packet or a light coat of oil to prevent rust. With this routine, a carbon steel griddle can last decades and improve its nonstick performance over time.
What size griddle do I need for a two-burner stove?
For a standard 30-inch stove with two burners side by side, a 22-inch by 10-inch griddle (like the YETI or Maverick) is the maximum that will fit without overhanging the burners. If your burners are spaced farther apart, you might need a 24-inch model, but measure the distance between burner centers first—most gas stoves have 8-10 inches between burners, so a 22-inch pan covers both evenly. A 17-inch round griddle is a better choice if you only want to use one burner, and it’s easier to store. For home cooks who entertain, I’d suggest a 22-inch double-burner griddle; for everyday cooking, a 17-inch round offers more flexibility without dominating your stovetop.
Conclusion
After comparing all 15 options, the Made In 17″ Round Carbon Steel Griddle is my pick for best overall—it hits the sweet spot of 3mm thickness, even heating, and oven compatibility, making it a versatile workhorse for any kitchen. For the best value, the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Griddle delivers reliable performance at a fraction of the cost, though you’ll sacrifice some heat retention and handle ergonomics. If you want the absolute premium experience, the YETI Carbon Steel Griddle is built like a tank and excels on outdoor grills, but its 22-inch size and 12-pound weight limit it to dedicated outdoor use. Beginners should start with the OXO Obsidian 10-In Crepe and Pancake Griddle—its detachable silicone handle and pre-seasoned surface make learning to care for carbon steel less intimidating. For double-burner cooking on a gas stove, the Oklahoma Joe’s 19-Inch Carbon Steel Griddle offers dual handles and a wide cooking surface without the bulk of the YETI. Whichever you choose, remember that carbon steel rewards patience—season it well, clean it gently, and it will outlast every nonstick pan you’ve ever owned.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
